SCOTUS-Cases.net

Hale v. Frost

99 U.S. 389 1878-10 1,273 Words
Full Case Caption
Hale v. Frost
Official & Parallel Citations
99 U.S. 389 · 25 L. Ed. 419
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 99 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Hale v. Frost.

1. Mortgages of the road and present and subsequently acquired property oí a railroad company, executed to secure the payment of its bonds, are, while it retains possession, a prior lien upon the net earnings of the road.

2. The net earnings, while the road is in possession of a receiver appointed by the court, may be applied to the payment of claims having superior equities to that of the bondholders. So held, where from such earnings payment was made to parties who had, before his appointment, furnished the company with car-springs, and spirals and supplies for its machinery department, which he continued to use in carrying on the business of the road.

Appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Iowa.

Between 1867 and 1873, The Burlington, Cedar Rapids, and Minnesota Railway Company, a corporation duly organized under the laws of Iowa, built and put in operation its main line from Burlington, via Cedar Rapids, to Plymouth; the Pacific Division, extending west from the main line at Vinton; the Muscatine Division, extending from Muscatine west across the main line ; and the Milwaukee Extension, extending from the main line near Cedar Rapids to Postville. The main [ine was mortgaged May, 1869 ; the Pacific Division, September, 1871; the Milwaukee Extension, January, 1872 ; and the' Muscatine Division, July, 1872. The mortgages were made to trustees to secure the bonds of the company, and covered the road, all rights of way, rolling-stock, and equipmént; all implements, fuel, and materials for the construction, operating, repairing, or replacing the road or any of its branches ; and also all franchises connecting with or relating to the road, which were then held or might thereafter be acquired by the company; and also all rights,-claims, and benefits in and to all leases, contracts, and agreements then made or which might thereafter be made with any parties whomsoever, together with 'all and singular the tenements and appurtenances thereunto belonging, and the reversions, remainders, tolls, incomes, rents, issues, and profits thereof, and also all the estates, rights, titles, and interests whatsoever, as well at law as in equity, of the company. The mortgages were authorized by statute, and were in due time and in the proper offices recorded.

The company, Nov. 1, 1873, made default in paying interest due for the preceding six months. The bondholders funded their interest coupons due respectively at that date and at six and twelve months next thereafter, and allowed the company to retain the possession of the road. The company, May 1, 1875, again made default in the payment of interest; and on the 19th of that month the trustees filed a bill against the company, to foreclose the several mortgages. A receiver was thereupon appointed by the court, who took immediate possession of the road and its branches. The company has never since had possession of them, or received any of the rents or profits thereof.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Waite

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Waite

announced the decision of the court.

- The first question certified in this case is answered in the affirmative, upon the authority of Fosdick v. Schall, supra, p. 235.

The third question is answered in the same way upon the same authority. The Union Car-Spring Manufacturing Company is entitled to payment in full, and Hale, Ayer, & Co. to payment of so much of their claim only as is for supplies to the machinery department. There is nothing in the case to show any special equities in their favor in respect to that part of their account which is for material for construction purposes.

An answer to the second question is unnecessary.

The several decrees appealed from will be reversed, and the cause remanded with instructions to enter decrees in favor of the appellants for the amount due them respectively from the fund in court, upon the principles settled by the answers which are’ given to the questions certified; and it is

iSo ordered.

Cited By Later Decisions (4)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).